Comment: Virginia future governors, GA, wake and smell the nuke coffee! Never, I mean never say "We Want to be like France"! France has problems with their Nukes! NO to Nukes! No to uranium mining! Tue Sep 15, 2009 11:00am EDT
Marignac Says "Far From Being a Model, France Should be a Powerful Cautionary
Tale for the U.S. about the Folly of a Headlong Rush into More Nuclear Power"
WASHINGTON, Sept. 15 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- U.S. policy makers are in the grips of "dangerous and costly illusions" if they think that France is a model showing how nuclear power could be implemented aggressively in the United States, according to Yves Marignac, a leading international consultant on nuclear energy issues and the executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris.
In visits this week with state and federal officials, Marignac is debunking the myth of the so-called "French nuclear model" that is being touted as a blueprint for the revival of the embattled nuclear power industry in the U.S.
Marignac Says "Far From Being a Model, France Should be a Powerful Cautionary
Tale for the U.S. about the Folly of a Headlong Rush into More Nuclear Power"
WASHINGTON, Sept. 15 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- U.S. policy makers are in the grips of "dangerous and costly illusions" if they think that France is a model showing how nuclear power could be implemented aggressively in the United States, according to Yves Marignac, a leading international consultant on nuclear energy issues and the executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris.
In visits this week with state and federal officials, Marignac is debunking the myth of the so-called "French nuclear model" that is being touted as a blueprint for the revival of the embattled nuclear power industry in the U.S.
His visit comes at a particular key time, as the U.S. Senate considers additional subsidies to the nuclear industry in its version of pending climate legislation and the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) seeks public comment on weakening the rules for loan-guarantee bailouts of proposed new reactors.
Yves Marignac said: "I am at a loss to understand how the United States could be so far off the mark in its understanding of the French experience with nuclear power.
The so-called 'success story' of the French nuclear program, which is being promoted so assiduously by the U.S. nuclear industry, is a complete disconnect with the stark reality of the 50-year history of rising costs, steadily worsening delays, technological dead-ends,failed industrialchallenges and planning mistakes.
If American policymakers are going to weigh the example of France, they need to get the facts instead of settling for the fantasy being sold to them by the US nuclear industry."
In his remarks today, Marignac noted the following key problems:
-- French nuclear technology is deeply flawed.
The French EPR Reactor is a new reactor design developed by the company Areva in cooperation with the German firm Siemens. British and Finnish nuclear regulators have also raised significant safety questions, in particular about the computerized command and control
system proposed for these reactors.
-- French nuclear reactor construction delays are getting steadily worse,
not better. Alongside increasing costs, construction times have
proven to be problematic. The last four reactors that were built in France,
two units in Chooz and two in Civaux, were only connected on average 10.5
years after construction work began, and subsequent safety problems
caused further delays. Their official industrial service only started
in 2000 and 2002 respectively, some 15.5 and 12.5 years after construction
started.
-- French nuclear reactor costs are just as out of control as they are in
the U.S. The EPR has been promoted as a technology that makes nuclear energy cheaper and more competitive. When the decision was made to build an EPR in Finland in 2002, the government promised that it would cost Euro 2.5 billion and take only four years to build. The final contract, three years later, put the price at Euro 3 billion and construction time was set at 4.5 years. Since construction began in summer 2005, a variety of technical problems have led to a three and a half-year delay, extending the construction period to at least 7 years.
system proposed for these reactors.
-- French nuclear reactor construction delays are getting steadily worse,
not better. Alongside increasing costs, construction times have
proven to be problematic. The last four reactors that were built in France,
two units in Chooz and two in Civaux, were only connected on average 10.5
years after construction work began, and subsequent safety problems
caused further delays. Their official industrial service only started
in 2000 and 2002 respectively, some 15.5 and 12.5 years after construction
started.
-- French nuclear reactor costs are just as out of control as they are in
the U.S. The EPR has been promoted as a technology that makes nuclear energy cheaper and more competitive. When the decision was made to build an EPR in Finland in 2002, the government promised that it would cost Euro 2.5 billion and take only four years to build. The final contract, three years later, put the price at Euro 3 billion and construction time was set at 4.5 years. Since construction began in summer 2005, a variety of technical problems have led to a three and a half-year delay, extending the construction period to at least 7 years.
-- Nuclear power in France has not promoted energy independence. Nuclear
power in France is a major presence, providing 76 percent of electricity produced in 2008. However, electricity accounted for only 20.7 percent of the final energy consumption in France that year. Nuclear power cannot provide energy security, as it only has a marginal effect upon oil consumption, which is dominated by the transport sector. France consumes more oil per capita than the European average, and despite its long-term objective to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by three-quarters, it seems incapable of bucking an upward trend. This is due largely to the weak policies on energy efficiency and new energy sources, influenced by the lock-in of nuclear power.
-- French nuclear power is not "safer" . . . and the nation does not have a long term solution to waste storage. The operators of the 200 nuclear facilities in France declare a very large number of events - considered relevant for safety - every year. EDF alone declares between 10,000 and 12,000, of which 700 to 800 are deemed "incidents" or "significant events. This total does not account for some 12,000 m3 of waste from the reprocessing plant in Marcoule that was dumped into the sea in 1967 and 1969. While reprocessing is presented as a means to reduce the volume of highly-radioactive long-lived wastes in final disposal, it actually increases the complexity of waste management, and thereby the danger for the population and environment. Reprocessing comes with numerous extra nuclear facilities and transports, each creating extra safety risks.
But also 'normal' radiation exposure arising from routine operations increases, for example by the radioactive discharges of La Hague reprocessing plants, with authorized discharge levels up to 1000 times higher than those applying to the nearby Flamanville nuclear power station. And even France, supposedly the country of nuclear expertise, has no long-term solution for its nuclear wastes.
-- Nuclear power in France is not popular.
The pursuit of the nuclear program in France is a permanently undemocratic choice. Contrary to the image presented in the United States, the French population is no more in favor of nuclear power than the European average - indeed a majority is opposed to the building of new plants. Surveys repeatedly show that the public lacks confidence in the institutional promoters of nuclear power.
-- The "nationalized" nuclear model in France is completely incompatible with the market-driven U.S.
In 2001, Compagnie Generale des Matieres Nucleaires (Cogema - General Company for Nuclear Materials), a private company established in 1976, merged with Framatome, the nuclear reactor builder, to create the Areva group. Currently, 96 percent of the share capital of the Areva group is held by the French state and large French industries.
-- State ownership of French nuclear power means that the true costs are hidden.
-- State ownership of French nuclear power means that the true costs are hidden.
Though largely in an indirect fashion, French taxpayers bear a large part of the nuclear costs. ABOUT YVES MARIGNAC
Yves Marignac is executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris, which he joined in 1997, after four years shared between academic research at Paris-XI University and applied studies in the French nuclear institute CEA and the nuclear company STMI. (go to link to read all his great works against Nukes)SOURCE Yves Marignac, WISE-Paris, and Nuclear Information and Resource Service Ailis Aaron Wolf, +1-703-276-3265 or aawolf@hastingsgroup.com, for Yves Marignac
Leading European Industry Expert to Debunk Myth of 'French Nuclear Model' For U.S.
Mon Sep 14, 2009 11:00am EDT
50 Years of French Failings in Nuclear Power Seen As Poor Model for U.S.; Nation's Nuclear Woes Seen Escalating in Huge Cost Overruns at Finnish, Flamanville Reactor Projects
Yves Marignac, a leading international consultant on nuclear energy issues and the executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris, will hold a major U.S. news media briefing at 11 a.m. EDT on September 15, 2009 to challenge the myth of the so-called "French nuclear model" that supposedly could serve as a blueprint for the revival of the embattled industry in the U.S.
Yves Marignac is executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris, which he joined in 1997, after four years shared between academic research at Paris-XI University and applied studies in the French nuclear institute CEA and the nuclear company STMI. (go to link to read all his great works against Nukes)SOURCE Yves Marignac, WISE-Paris, and Nuclear Information and Resource Service Ailis Aaron Wolf, +1-703-276-3265 or aawolf@hastingsgroup.com, for Yves Marignac
Leading European Industry Expert to Debunk Myth of 'French Nuclear Model' For U.S.
Mon Sep 14, 2009 11:00am EDT
50 Years of French Failings in Nuclear Power Seen As Poor Model for U.S.; Nation's Nuclear Woes Seen Escalating in Huge Cost Overruns at Finnish, Flamanville Reactor Projects
Yves Marignac, a leading international consultant on nuclear energy issues and the executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris, will hold a major U.S. news media briefing at 11 a.m. EDT on September 15, 2009 to challenge the myth of the so-called "French nuclear model" that supposedly could serve as a blueprint for the revival of the embattled industry in the U.S.
As the U.S. Senate considers additional subsidies to the nuclear industry in its version of pending climate legislation and the U.S. Department of Energy (DoE) seeks public comment on weakening the rules for loan-guarantee bail-outs of proposed new reactors, Marignac is visiting the United States to meet with federal and state officials, among other groups.
He will outline how the "nuclear success story" myth that is being promoted by the U.S. nuclear industry is far removed from the reality of France's 50-year history of technological dead-ends, failed industrial challenges and planning mistakes. Marignac will highlight how these problems have accelerated in recent years with the design flaws, construction problems and ever-escalating cost overruns now plaguing the troubled reactor projects at Olkiluoto 3 in
Finland and Flamanville-3 in France.
Yves Marignac is executive director of the energy information agency WISE-Paris, which he joined in 1997, after four years shared between academic research at Paris-XI University and applied studies in the French nuclear institute CEA and the nuclear company STMI.
His consultant work covers a wide range of nuclear issues for various institutional bodies and NGOs at the national and international level. In 1999-2000, Marignac participated in the economic evaluation of the nuclear option commissioned by French Prime Minister (known as Charpin-Dessus-Pellat report), and in 2001 he was a co-author of a report to the European Parliament's Scientific and Technological Option Assessment (STOA) Panel on reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel. In 2005, he acted as consultant to the Commission that organized the
institutional public debate on the project of the new French reactor, EPR (Flamanville-3).
Marignac is the author or co-author of a number of books and other publications, including Nuclear Power, the Great Illusion - Promises, Setbacks and Threats (October 2008) and Spent Nuclear Fuel Reprocessing in France (April 2008).
TO PARTICIPATE: You can join this live, phone-based news conference (with full, two-way Q&A) at 11 a.m. EDT on September 15, 2009 by dialing 1 (800) 860-2442. Ask for the "debunking the French 'nuclear model'" news event.
CAN'T PARTICIPATE?: A streaming audio replay of the news event will be available on the Web at http://www.nuclearbailout.org as of 5 p.m. EDT on September 15, 2009.
CONTACT: Ailis Aaron Wolf, +1-703-276-3265, aawolf@hastingsgroup.com, for Yves
Marignac, of WISE-Paris /PRNewswire-USNewswire -- Sept. 14/ SOURCE Yves Marignac, of WISE-Paris
http://www.reuters.com/article/pressRelease/idUS148422+15-Sep-2009+PRN20090915
