Comment: Great Letter, Ms. Maute
Open-Minded (Open-Mined) on Uranium Mine Study
Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram, in his recent editorial, says he believes in the importance of science-based study to determine the safety of mining. Curiously, at this late date, he expresses concern "that no one from Pittsylvania County is on the panel convened by the National Academy." He's about 2 years too late. Having no local representation on the Coal and Energy Commission and National Academy of Sciences is old news. Where was Ingram when these decisions were being debated and determined?
He now advocates that four open-minded citizens be placed on the panel to represent our best interests and to be a part of the study and deliberations in reaching findings as to whether mining is safe. Why this eleventh hour concern for citizen participation in the process? Is he, or someone else, having doubts regarding the ability of NAS to deliver the intended goods? Is Ingram concerned that the NAS may articulate the risks involved regarding uranium mining and milling in Virginia?
Who might he consider an "open-minded citizen"? Does he mean open-minded (open-mined) to the prospect of mining and milling of uranium or open to safegarding citizen's health, welfare and water resouces? Perhaps he means those who know nothing...the kind of people government seems to embrace regarding decision making. Who will aid Mr. Ingram in determining these open-minded citizens to help determine our fate?
I smell a rat. Whose agenda is Ingram really trying to advance?
Karen B. Maute
Mining: Decision time draws near
By Published by The Editorial Board
Published: February 2, 2010
To the editor:
It is time to move beyond non-binding resolutions regarding uranium mining and get to the real issues at hand.
All of us on the Board of Supervisors, as well as most sensible citizens, agree on the importance of the science-based study to determine the safety of mining. We should now wait for the findings of the National Academy of Sciences before taking any further action.
In the meantime, I remain concerned that no one from Pittsylvania County is on the panel convened by the National Academy. I believe we should have at least four open-minded citizens on the panel to represent our best interests and to be a part of the study — and a part of the deliberations in reaching findings as to whether mining is safe. I intend to ask the Board of Supervisors to send a letter making this request to the National Academy.
I offer these thoughts in the spirit of compromise and, I hope, reconciliation. My hope is not to squelch vigorous debate among board members but to encourage the unity we all would like to see on the board. There will be many points along the way involving permitting and zoning in which the board will have specific authority to be sure the right course is allowed.
I hope, too, that my resolve not to support any further resolutions on the uranium issue will clear the air as we await the results of the science-based study to provide us with hard facts instead of emotion in assessing the merits of the project.
I agree with many others — and as I told Gov. Bob McDonnell — that if the National Academy of Sciences finds that mining can be done safely, we must all be prepared to move ahead vigorously to bring new jobs and a fresh sense of prosperity to our region.
FRED INGRAM
Supervisor, Gretna-Callands District
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/opinion/letters_to_the_editor/danville_letters/article/mining_decision_time_draws_near/17589/
Showing posts with label board of supervisors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label board of supervisors. Show all posts
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Friday, January 29, 2010
Supervisors reject ban on uranium mining around Berry Hill mega park
Comment: What would happen if the mega park failed to develop and the land belongs to RIFA, will RIFA mine and mill uranium then with the taxpayers paying for the land? We want the resolution to ban uranium mining and milling all over our county but we demand the ban in the Mega Park at Berry Hill! Also, several board of supervisors own land within 25 miles of the park! Maybe they should not have voted on the resolution!
By TIM DAVIS/Star-Tribune Editor
Wednesday, January 27, 2010 9:18 AM EST
The Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors voted 4-3 last Tuesday to reject a proposed ban on uranium mining and milling in and around the county's Berry Hill Road "mega" industrial park.
Karen Maute of Danville, an outspoken advocate for the environment, asked supervisors to protect the industrial park in November and repeated her concerns in December.
"I think it's very important that we protect the park," she said, urging supervisors to "dispel" rumors the county may use the property for uranium mining and milling.
Pittsylvania County and Danville, acting through the Danville-Pittsylvania Regional Industrial Facilities Authority, have spent about $13 million for land along Berry Hill Road, just west of Danville.
Officials plan to develop a state-certified 4,000-acre "mega" industrial park, with both localities sharing expenses and revenue.
According to County Administrator Dan Sleeper, it may cost $220 million to develop the huge industrial park.
Maute opposes uranium mining at Coles Hill near Chatham, and has repeatedly asked supervisors to tighten the county's zoning ordinance to block the proposed mine and mill.
In her proposed resolution, she pointed out some of the Berry Hill property had mineral leases with Marline Uranium Corp., which discovered the huge uranium deposit in the late 1970s.
In order to avoid the appearance that the county and city are entering into a "joint uranium mining venture," she said both localities should sign a resolution prohibiting uranium mining and milling within a 25-mile radius of the Berry Hill park.
The resolution was later changed to a 20-mile radius to avoid including Coles Hill.
Maute said the resolution would protect the region's investment in the mega park and create a "safe haven" for residents.
Staunton River District Supervisor Marshall Ecker agreed, and made a motion in December to approve the resolution and ask Danville to do the same.
"I believe this board should step up to the plate and make sure the mega park investment is protected in case the state ever lifts the ban on uranium mining," Ecker said.
Chatham-Blairs District Supervisor Henry "Hank" Davis Jr. seconded Ecker's motion for discussion, but Dan River District Supervisor James Snead made a substitute motion to table it.
Ecker had the resolution back on the board's agenda last week where it met a similar fate.
Ecker, Davis and Callands-Gretna District Supervisor Fred Ingram voted for it. Pritchett, Barber, Snead and Harville voted against it.
Harville, who is chairman of the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority, said the county has no intention of mining uranium at Berry Hill.
"We bought it for a mega park. That's it - cut and dry," he said.
In negotiating to buy the land, Harville said the authority insisted on purchasing mineral rights to protect the park from future uranium mining.
"We never considered that (uranium mining) and never had it on the table. We didn't buy the park for that," Harville said.
Ecker still believes the ban is important for the industrial park.
"It shows businesses that may come to the park that the board is interested in protecting their investment," he said. "It's also to protect the citizens' investment of $220 million."
In addition to Maute, several residents spoke in favor of the proposed ban at last week's supervisors' meeting in Chatham.
Deborah Dix of Blairs said the regional authority amounts to "taxation without representation."
"I don't want my tax money going to uranium mining and milling," she said.
North Carolina residents also expressed concern about possible contamination of the Dan River, which borders the mega park.
tim.davis@chathamstartribune.com
434-432-2791
Read more:
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2010/01/27/chatham/news/news51.txt
By TIM DAVIS/Star-Tribune Editor
Wednesday, January 27, 2010 9:18 AM EST
The Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors voted 4-3 last Tuesday to reject a proposed ban on uranium mining and milling in and around the county's Berry Hill Road "mega" industrial park.
Karen Maute of Danville, an outspoken advocate for the environment, asked supervisors to protect the industrial park in November and repeated her concerns in December.
"I think it's very important that we protect the park," she said, urging supervisors to "dispel" rumors the county may use the property for uranium mining and milling.
Pittsylvania County and Danville, acting through the Danville-Pittsylvania Regional Industrial Facilities Authority, have spent about $13 million for land along Berry Hill Road, just west of Danville.
Officials plan to develop a state-certified 4,000-acre "mega" industrial park, with both localities sharing expenses and revenue.
According to County Administrator Dan Sleeper, it may cost $220 million to develop the huge industrial park.
Maute opposes uranium mining at Coles Hill near Chatham, and has repeatedly asked supervisors to tighten the county's zoning ordinance to block the proposed mine and mill.
In her proposed resolution, she pointed out some of the Berry Hill property had mineral leases with Marline Uranium Corp., which discovered the huge uranium deposit in the late 1970s.
In order to avoid the appearance that the county and city are entering into a "joint uranium mining venture," she said both localities should sign a resolution prohibiting uranium mining and milling within a 25-mile radius of the Berry Hill park.
The resolution was later changed to a 20-mile radius to avoid including Coles Hill.
Maute said the resolution would protect the region's investment in the mega park and create a "safe haven" for residents.
Staunton River District Supervisor Marshall Ecker agreed, and made a motion in December to approve the resolution and ask Danville to do the same.
"I believe this board should step up to the plate and make sure the mega park investment is protected in case the state ever lifts the ban on uranium mining," Ecker said.
Chatham-Blairs District Supervisor Henry "Hank" Davis Jr. seconded Ecker's motion for discussion, but Dan River District Supervisor James Snead made a substitute motion to table it.
Ecker had the resolution back on the board's agenda last week where it met a similar fate.
Ecker, Davis and Callands-Gretna District Supervisor Fred Ingram voted for it. Pritchett, Barber, Snead and Harville voted against it.
Harville, who is chairman of the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority, said the county has no intention of mining uranium at Berry Hill.
"We bought it for a mega park. That's it - cut and dry," he said.
In negotiating to buy the land, Harville said the authority insisted on purchasing mineral rights to protect the park from future uranium mining.
"We never considered that (uranium mining) and never had it on the table. We didn't buy the park for that," Harville said.
Ecker still believes the ban is important for the industrial park.
"It shows businesses that may come to the park that the board is interested in protecting their investment," he said. "It's also to protect the citizens' investment of $220 million."
In addition to Maute, several residents spoke in favor of the proposed ban at last week's supervisors' meeting in Chatham.
Deborah Dix of Blairs said the regional authority amounts to "taxation without representation."
"I don't want my tax money going to uranium mining and milling," she said.
North Carolina residents also expressed concern about possible contamination of the Dan River, which borders the mega park.
tim.davis@chathamstartribune.com
434-432-2791
Read more:
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2010/01/27/chatham/news/news51.txt
Supervisor Marshall Ecker's report/Resolution on ban mining and milling of uranium at the Berry Hill Mega Park
Comment: Thanks Mr. Ecker for all you do and listening to your people about the problems of uranium mining!
Wednesday, January 27, 2010 9:17 AM EST
The New Year has started out with a new chairman of the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors.
Thanks to Banister District Supervisor William Pritchett, the board voted 4-3 to elect Chatham-Blairs District's Hank Davis as chairman.
Let's hope things will change for the good for all Pittsylvania County.
I still believe that the chairman should be rotated to all board members and not dominated by one person.
That is why I voted for Mr. Davis, plus I feel he will do a good job.
2010 will be a tough year with less money from state, dealing with new budget demands from all departments and trying to find ways to pay for it from local monies.
Last year I introduced a program to have employees come up with ways to save and eliminate waste.
The board vote 7-0 for this proposal, but to my knowledge no one has taken advantage of this program.
I would like your input on what would be good suggestions on how Pittsylvania County can save your tax dollars. We all need to work together in these tough times.
Uranium ban
This leads me up to the resolution to ban mining and milling of uranium at the Berry Hill Mega Park.
The resolution did not ban uranium mining or milling in all of Pittsylvania County or at Coles Hill.
This was to protect your tax dollars - all $222 million- in a 20-mile radius around the Berry Hill project.
If the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority (RIFA) has no intention of mining or milling of uranium in Berry Hill Mega Park, why not pass a resolution to protect future business investments?
Our neighbors to the south (North Carolina) are concerned about the Dan River, which is a source of their drinking water.
Virginia Beach is concerned. They are spending almost half a million dollars for a study on the quality of their drinking water (most comes from or flows through Pittsylvania County) if the moratorium is lifted in Virginia.
Here in Pittsylvania County, those in position of power are failing to make any decisions. The resolution failed 4-3.
Our job as leaders in Pittsylvania County is to protect the health, safety and welfare of its citizens. When will be the right time: before or after something happens?
Board packet
To get the Board of Supervisors' packet or other information, you need to go to Pittsylvania County's home page, www.pittgov.org , and click on large letters Agendas/Minutes/Packets/Public Hearings.
This is a tool for all citizens to use and help to keep a watchful eye on county business.
Feel free to contact me by telephone at 434-335-5967 (Please, no phone calls after 9 p.m.)
Or you can e-mail me at any hour at marshall.ecker@pittgov.org.
I want to know your thoughts or ideas on issues that are important to you.
Marshall Ecker represents the Staunton River District on the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors.
Read more:
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2010/01/28/chatham/opinion/opinion07.txt
Wednesday, January 27, 2010 9:17 AM EST
The New Year has started out with a new chairman of the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors.
Thanks to Banister District Supervisor William Pritchett, the board voted 4-3 to elect Chatham-Blairs District's Hank Davis as chairman.
Let's hope things will change for the good for all Pittsylvania County.
I still believe that the chairman should be rotated to all board members and not dominated by one person.
That is why I voted for Mr. Davis, plus I feel he will do a good job.
2010 will be a tough year with less money from state, dealing with new budget demands from all departments and trying to find ways to pay for it from local monies.
Last year I introduced a program to have employees come up with ways to save and eliminate waste.
The board vote 7-0 for this proposal, but to my knowledge no one has taken advantage of this program.
I would like your input on what would be good suggestions on how Pittsylvania County can save your tax dollars. We all need to work together in these tough times.
Uranium ban
This leads me up to the resolution to ban mining and milling of uranium at the Berry Hill Mega Park.
The resolution did not ban uranium mining or milling in all of Pittsylvania County or at Coles Hill.
This was to protect your tax dollars - all $222 million- in a 20-mile radius around the Berry Hill project.
If the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority (RIFA) has no intention of mining or milling of uranium in Berry Hill Mega Park, why not pass a resolution to protect future business investments?
Our neighbors to the south (North Carolina) are concerned about the Dan River, which is a source of their drinking water.
Virginia Beach is concerned. They are spending almost half a million dollars for a study on the quality of their drinking water (most comes from or flows through Pittsylvania County) if the moratorium is lifted in Virginia.
Here in Pittsylvania County, those in position of power are failing to make any decisions. The resolution failed 4-3.
Our job as leaders in Pittsylvania County is to protect the health, safety and welfare of its citizens. When will be the right time: before or after something happens?
Board packet
To get the Board of Supervisors' packet or other information, you need to go to Pittsylvania County's home page, www.pittgov.org , and click on large letters Agendas/Minutes/Packets/Public Hearings.
This is a tool for all citizens to use and help to keep a watchful eye on county business.
Feel free to contact me by telephone at 434-335-5967 (Please, no phone calls after 9 p.m.)
Or you can e-mail me at any hour at marshall.ecker@pittgov.org.
I want to know your thoughts or ideas on issues that are important to you.
Marshall Ecker represents the Staunton River District on the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors.
Read more:
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2010/01/28/chatham/opinion/opinion07.txt
Monday, January 11, 2010
Regional Industrial Facility Authority Board doesn’t plan uranium mining resolution at megapark
Comment: When was this discussed before the board without the citizens and how was it voted on? Is Ace seeing things occurring behind closed doors? Is this legal? Is this board taking taxpayer money and the park could become a uranium mining or have a uranium mill with taxpayer’s money? We do not want uranium mining or milling in our county! Demand our Board of Supervisors to ban uranium mining and milling throughout our county but it must be done at the Mega Park now or give money back to the citizens!
By John Crane
Published: January 11, 2010
RINGGOLD — The chairman of the Regional Industrial Facility Authority board said Monday the group has no plans to pass a resolution banning uranium mining at the Berry Hill Road industrial megapark.
“It hasn’t been brought to us,” said Coy Harville, RIFA board chairman said after the RIFA board’s meeting Monday.
Karen Maute, an opponent of uranium mining and milling, asked the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors in November to pass a resolution prohibiting uranium mining within a 25-mile radius of the proposed Berry Hill Road industrial megapark site. She also wants the Board of Supervisors, Danville City Council and the RIFA board to sign the resolution. The Board of Supervisors voted to table the idea during its meeting in December.
Pittsylvania County and Danville hope to attract a major manufacturer to the site. Pittsylvania County Administrator Dan Sleeper said last month that installation of roads, utilities, erosion control, grading and making the site into an industry-ready park will cost $222 million.
Maute proposed the resolution because the 3,700-acre megapark site includes historic Marline mineral leases. Marline Corp. had plans to mine and mill uranium in Pittsylvania County in the early 1980s. Maute’s resolution points to at least one former Marline parcel covering 504 acres. RIFA owns the leases.
The Board of Supervisors voted to table the idea during its meeting Dec. 15, but not before Staunton River Supervisor Marshall Ecker urged the board to pass the resolution to protect county taxpayers’ investment.
“I believe that this board should step up to the plate,” Ecker said last month.
But Dan River Supervisor James Snead made a substitute motion to table the matter and the board, by a narrow 4-3 vote, passed it. Snead, Tunstall Supervisor Tim Barber, Banister Supervisor William Pritchett and Westover Supervisor and then-Board Chairman Coy Harville voted in favor. Ecker, Chatham-Blairs Supervisor (and current Chairman) Hank Davis and Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram opposed Snead’s motion.
Snead said after the December meeting that the resolution should come from the RIFA board since it owns the park.
Coy Harville, who was chairman of the board of supervisors last year, said after the December meeting he would discuss the proposed resolution with the board and RIFA before commenting on it.
“We’re taking it under consideration,” Harville had said after the December meeting.
But after Monday’s RIFA board meeting, Harville said, referring to Snead’s assertion that the resolution should come through the RIFA board, “that was one supervisor’s statement, not the board’s.”
The proposal was brought to the board of supervisors, not RIFA, Harville said.
Any items to be considered for the RIFA agenda must be brought to the board’s clerk, he said.
Maute said: “If Mr. Harville says it should be brought before RIFA, that’s where the request would be placed.”
However, Maute said, “I still think it’s a county issue,” since the megapark is in the county.
RIFA has no intention of mining uranium at the Berry Hill megapark site, he said.
Read more:
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/local/danville_news/article/board_doesnt_plan_uranium_mining_resolution_at_megapark/16962/
Tuesday, January 5, 2010
In surprise move, Davis tapped to lead Pittsylvania County board
Comment: Good luck to Mr. Davis, he listens to his people and we hope he will continue to listen to reason!
By John Crane
Published: January 4, 2010
CHATHAM — It was an unexpected turn of events during the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors’ reorganization meeting Monday night. Underdog Chatham-Blairs Supervisor Hank Davis took the chairmanship in a narrow 4-3 vote.
Davis had lost contests for chairman in past years, but this time he emerged victorious when Banister Supervisor William Pritchett voted for Davis, tilting the margin in his favor. The vote ended Westover Supervisor Coy Harville’s run as chairman.
“This is as much news to me as it is to you,” a surprised Davis said as he took the chairman’s seat on the board. “I’m very appreciative that the board saw fit to elect me. I’ll do all I can to (take) this county forward.”
“I do plan to keep this board as unified as possible,” he added.
Pritchett said he voted for Davis because “I felt like he would make a good chairman. I want to bring unity to the board.”
The board’s vote once again highlighted the north-south split on the board!
Staunton River Supervisor Marshall Ecker, Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram, Davis and Pritchett voting for Davis, with Dan River Supervisor James Snead, Tunstall Supervisor Tim Barber, and Harville voting against.
Ingram had nominated Davis while Ecker seconded.
Read more:
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/local/danville_news/article/in_surprise_move_davis_to_lead_pittsylvania_county_board/16787/
By John Crane
Published: January 4, 2010
CHATHAM — It was an unexpected turn of events during the Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors’ reorganization meeting Monday night. Underdog Chatham-Blairs Supervisor Hank Davis took the chairmanship in a narrow 4-3 vote.
Davis had lost contests for chairman in past years, but this time he emerged victorious when Banister Supervisor William Pritchett voted for Davis, tilting the margin in his favor. The vote ended Westover Supervisor Coy Harville’s run as chairman.
“This is as much news to me as it is to you,” a surprised Davis said as he took the chairman’s seat on the board. “I’m very appreciative that the board saw fit to elect me. I’ll do all I can to (take) this county forward.”
“I do plan to keep this board as unified as possible,” he added.
Pritchett said he voted for Davis because “I felt like he would make a good chairman. I want to bring unity to the board.”
The board’s vote once again highlighted the north-south split on the board!
Staunton River Supervisor Marshall Ecker, Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram, Davis and Pritchett voting for Davis, with Dan River Supervisor James Snead, Tunstall Supervisor Tim Barber, and Harville voting against.
Ingram had nominated Davis while Ecker seconded.
Read more:
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/local/danville_news/article/in_surprise_move_davis_to_lead_pittsylvania_county_board/16787/
Wednesday, December 30, 2009
Support for uranium no surprise
Comment: Great Letter and Thanks! No to uranium mining and milling!
By Published by The Editorial Board
Published: December 29, 2009
Updated: December 30, 2009
To the editor:
I am shocked! Shocked!
To read in the Danville Register & Bee that Fred Ingram supports uranium mining in Southside Virginia!
Imagine, a man for whom the nuclear power industry provided food for his table and clothing for his family for 20 years, now makes a dramatic statement in favor of a major aspect of that very industry!
Gee, what other startling revelations await me in the pages of my morning newspaper? How about the fact that the coming winter will be cold, or maybe, that night brings on darkness? Could there ever be a more dog-bites-man story than that which involves Fred Ingram and his support of uranium mining?
Interesting, too, are these unctuous caveats of caution on the part of uranium mine supporters (Ingram and others): Only if its safe. What does that mean? Such pretentious bloviations feign care and concern for the speakers fellow citizens of Southside, when at the same time, hiding with total contempt the facts of the situation.
It is as if Gen. William T. Sherman himself had stated that he was all for marching through Georgia, but only if it had no negative effects on the civilian population.
Uranium mining is by definition damaging to the environment and ruinous on local land values and local economies. There is not one example in the United States of it doing otherwise. Not one.
What can be the meaning, then, of these bizarre pronouncements? Is it to display the speaker’s total ignorance of what uranium mining is and what it causes? Is it to show total disdain for one’s fellow citizens, whose future lies in their elected hands? Is it in anticipation of financial gain?
That’s really the story the Register & Bee’s reporters should go after, because that’s the real mystery.
Oh, and it was also telling that, after we are assured mining will proceed only if its safe, we are told that there’s lots of money in them thar Sheva hills.
Sherman’s March was a lucrative enterprise, too, only not to the people of Georgia and the Carolinas who experienced it. It was a great windfall to Detroit, Cleveland, New York and Chicago. It even catapulted Gen. Sherman to national fame and, though he later refused it, political prominence. Therein, perhaps, lies a moral tale for us all.
RICHARD DIXON
Chatham, VA
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/opinion/letters_to_the_editor/danville_letters/article/support_for_uranium_no_surprise/16682/
By Published by The Editorial Board
Published: December 29, 2009
Updated: December 30, 2009
To the editor:
I am shocked! Shocked!
To read in the Danville Register & Bee that Fred Ingram supports uranium mining in Southside Virginia!
Imagine, a man for whom the nuclear power industry provided food for his table and clothing for his family for 20 years, now makes a dramatic statement in favor of a major aspect of that very industry!
Gee, what other startling revelations await me in the pages of my morning newspaper? How about the fact that the coming winter will be cold, or maybe, that night brings on darkness? Could there ever be a more dog-bites-man story than that which involves Fred Ingram and his support of uranium mining?
Interesting, too, are these unctuous caveats of caution on the part of uranium mine supporters (Ingram and others): Only if its safe. What does that mean? Such pretentious bloviations feign care and concern for the speakers fellow citizens of Southside, when at the same time, hiding with total contempt the facts of the situation.
It is as if Gen. William T. Sherman himself had stated that he was all for marching through Georgia, but only if it had no negative effects on the civilian population.
Uranium mining is by definition damaging to the environment and ruinous on local land values and local economies. There is not one example in the United States of it doing otherwise. Not one.
What can be the meaning, then, of these bizarre pronouncements? Is it to display the speaker’s total ignorance of what uranium mining is and what it causes? Is it to show total disdain for one’s fellow citizens, whose future lies in their elected hands? Is it in anticipation of financial gain?
That’s really the story the Register & Bee’s reporters should go after, because that’s the real mystery.
Oh, and it was also telling that, after we are assured mining will proceed only if its safe, we are told that there’s lots of money in them thar Sheva hills.
Sherman’s March was a lucrative enterprise, too, only not to the people of Georgia and the Carolinas who experienced it. It was a great windfall to Detroit, Cleveland, New York and Chicago. It even catapulted Gen. Sherman to national fame and, though he later refused it, political prominence. Therein, perhaps, lies a moral tale for us all.
RICHARD DIXON
Chatham, VA
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/opinion/letters_to_the_editor/danville_letters/article/support_for_uranium_no_surprise/16682/
Monday, December 21, 2009
December 2009 Supervisors report/Resolution to protect the Berry Hill Mega Park from uranium mining and milling
Comment: Thanks Mr. Ecker for the resolution but it failed as usually by the Gang of 4, they always look at their leader before they vote! This blog believes that the supervisor on the Regional Industrial Facilities Authority should not be able to vote on the resolution! The land belongs to the taxpayers and we do not want uranium mining or milling anywhere in our county and we do not want our tax money going toward uranium mining milling! Ban uranium mining and milling now!
Saturday, December 19, 2009
I tried to have a resolution to protect the Berry Hill Mega Park from uranium mining and milling should the state of Virginia allow it.
We as taxpayers will be investing well over $200 million dollars in this project.
I felt that we need to let potential business investors know that their investment would be protected and not for naught.
We need to let Pittsylvania County citizens know that Berry Hill Mega Park will not be a site for milling of uranium ore or mining of uranium on this land owned by Pittsylvania County and City of Danville.
Some members of this Board of Supervisors have again failed to insure that taxpayer’s dollars would be protected in this Mega Park.
By failing to take any action said to the people of Pittsylvania County that the potential exist that this site could be a site for milling of uranium ore should the moratorium on uranium mining be lifted in the State of Virginia.
One member of the Board of Supervisors was quoted as saying that this was a Regional Industrial Facilities Authority matter because they owned the land.
Guess what the citizens of Pittsylvania County and Danville city are the owners of this land because they are the ones who are paying the bill for this Mega Park.
The four members of Board decided to table this so no action would be taken, they want it to die and fade into the sunset. This subject will not go away unless the moratorium is not lifted forever in the State of Virginia.
Read more:
http://marshallecker.blogspot.com/
Thursday, December 17, 2009
Supervisor takes stand on uranium mining (Virginia)
Greed!
Comment: Well, Well, Mr. Ingram, you finally showed your true colors! Nuclear jobs are not the same as an open pit uranium mine or a nasty uranium mill! You are not listening to your people at every supervisors meeting when they bring facts about uranium mining problems in Canada and Australia where for a fact, uranium mining is not safe or green! Doctors are leaving the two countries because they state the fact that uranium mining is dangerous to our health! What the heck is wrong with you! We will never stop talking about the problems of uranium mining! How can two scientists perform a study, let's say uranium mining, one says it is safe and the other doctor says it is not safe? One scientist is paid by the nuclear and uranium group and the other doctor tells the truth! No to Uranium mining and milling!
By John Crane
Published: December 17, 2009
A Pittsylvania County supervisor has become the first on the board to take a firm public stand individually on the issue of uranium mining.
If a state study determines that uranium can be mined and milled safely at Coles Hill, then “let’s move on with it (mining),” Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram said Thursday.
“I think it’s only fair to everybody in Pittsylvania County that we put this to rest,” Ingram said.
Virginia Uranium Inc. seeks to mine and mill a 119-million pound uranium ore deposit at Coles Hill, about six miles northeast of Chatham. Virginia has had a moratorium on uranium mining since 1982. A study to determine whether uranium can be mined and milled safely in the commonwealth has received tentative approval from the National Research Council.
The Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a resolution in February requesting that a study finds no harm to the county, “its businesses, institutions, environment, and citizens by uranium, as opposed to a cost/benefit approach to this issue or simply accepting minimal damages.”
A proposal by a Pittsylvania County resident to prohibit uranium mining at the Berry Hill Road industrial megapark site hit a dead end during the board’s adjourned meeting Tuesday night. Supervisors voted to table the idea by a 4-3 vote. Karen Maute, a uranium mining opponent, asked the board last month to ban uranium mining within a 25-mile radius of the proposed industrial megapark site. Maute also wants Danville City Council and the Danville Pittsylvania Regional Industrial Facilities Authority to sign the resolution.
Maute proposed the resolution because the 3,700-acre megapark site includes historic Marline mineral leases. Marline Corp. had plans to mine and mill uranium in Pittsylvania County in the early 1980s.
Ingram, however, voted against tabling the proposal. Ingram opposes mining uranium at Berry Hill and perceives no inconsistency in his vote.
“I really don’t see what that had to do with Coles Hill,” said Ingram, who worked in the nuclear industry for 20 years at Babcock & Wilcox in Lynchburg.
Maute said Ingram’s view merely represents what the board has said all along about the issue.
If the study finds mining can be done safely, it would be an “anomaly,” she said. Maute’s research has not shown that it has been done safely anywhere in the world, she said.
However, Ingram said if the study finds that mining cannot be done safely, he would oppose VUI’s plans. Ingram said he’s more concerned about the socioeconomic aspects — including impacts on real-estate values - of uranium mining than the technical issues.
Read more at:
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/local/danville_news/article/supervisor_takes_stand_on_uranium_mining/16427/
Comment: Well, Well, Mr. Ingram, you finally showed your true colors! Nuclear jobs are not the same as an open pit uranium mine or a nasty uranium mill! You are not listening to your people at every supervisors meeting when they bring facts about uranium mining problems in Canada and Australia where for a fact, uranium mining is not safe or green! Doctors are leaving the two countries because they state the fact that uranium mining is dangerous to our health! What the heck is wrong with you! We will never stop talking about the problems of uranium mining! How can two scientists perform a study, let's say uranium mining, one says it is safe and the other doctor says it is not safe? One scientist is paid by the nuclear and uranium group and the other doctor tells the truth! No to Uranium mining and milling!
By John Crane
Published: December 17, 2009
A Pittsylvania County supervisor has become the first on the board to take a firm public stand individually on the issue of uranium mining.
If a state study determines that uranium can be mined and milled safely at Coles Hill, then “let’s move on with it (mining),” Callands-Gretna Supervisor Fred Ingram said Thursday.
“I think it’s only fair to everybody in Pittsylvania County that we put this to rest,” Ingram said.
Virginia Uranium Inc. seeks to mine and mill a 119-million pound uranium ore deposit at Coles Hill, about six miles northeast of Chatham. Virginia has had a moratorium on uranium mining since 1982. A study to determine whether uranium can be mined and milled safely in the commonwealth has received tentative approval from the National Research Council.
The Pittsylvania County Board of Supervisors unanimously approved a resolution in February requesting that a study finds no harm to the county, “its businesses, institutions, environment, and citizens by uranium, as opposed to a cost/benefit approach to this issue or simply accepting minimal damages.”
A proposal by a Pittsylvania County resident to prohibit uranium mining at the Berry Hill Road industrial megapark site hit a dead end during the board’s adjourned meeting Tuesday night. Supervisors voted to table the idea by a 4-3 vote. Karen Maute, a uranium mining opponent, asked the board last month to ban uranium mining within a 25-mile radius of the proposed industrial megapark site. Maute also wants Danville City Council and the Danville Pittsylvania Regional Industrial Facilities Authority to sign the resolution.
Maute proposed the resolution because the 3,700-acre megapark site includes historic Marline mineral leases. Marline Corp. had plans to mine and mill uranium in Pittsylvania County in the early 1980s.
Ingram, however, voted against tabling the proposal. Ingram opposes mining uranium at Berry Hill and perceives no inconsistency in his vote.
“I really don’t see what that had to do with Coles Hill,” said Ingram, who worked in the nuclear industry for 20 years at Babcock & Wilcox in Lynchburg.
Maute said Ingram’s view merely represents what the board has said all along about the issue.
If the study finds mining can be done safely, it would be an “anomaly,” she said. Maute’s research has not shown that it has been done safely anywhere in the world, she said.
However, Ingram said if the study finds that mining cannot be done safely, he would oppose VUI’s plans. Ingram said he’s more concerned about the socioeconomic aspects — including impacts on real-estate values - of uranium mining than the technical issues.
Read more at:
http://www2.godanriver.com/gdr/news/local/danville_news/article/supervisor_takes_stand_on_uranium_mining/16427/
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Ban stronger than moratorium (Uranium mining in VA)

Comment: Demand the county to BAN URANIUM MINING AND MILLING NOW!
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 9:33 AM EDT
I have been doing research on uranium mining and milling.
This is what I found: Marline stated that residents within a two-mile radius would have to relocate. Streams and wells would be lost for drinking purposes.
There was a study done in Michigan on the environmental impact on mining and milling of uranium.
Their findings for an open-pit uranium mine and mill was that there would have to be a buffer zone of 1,300 to 3,300 acres or two to five square miles.
Think a little bit. How many homes are in a square mile? How many acres of farm land will be useless? How many tax dollars the county will lose?
A couple of months ago, the county supervisors recognized the dairy farmers in the county.
The farmers stated in the last couple of years they hired 60 extra people.
The county will lose more tax revenue than it will gain if this mine and mill gets the ok.
The VanDerHyde's dairy is trying to get the ok and funding for an anaerobic digester to change cattle waste into electricity.
I think this is a good idea, and good for the environment.
None of this will happen when the air and water becomes contaminated.
People will not buy contaminated milk, hay, beef, or anything else raised or grown in the area surrounding a mine.
The mega park that the county supervisors have spent our tax money on will not happen. No company will come to this area if there are health risks.
Last November my wife and I, plus four others, went to West Virginia to see a mountain-top removal coal mine.
There was a town a few miles from the mine site. Everything was boarded up: schools, churches, gas stations, and stores.
It was a ghost town.
The mining company was following rules and regulations. Is this what we want for this county?
Don't wait for the study.
Mr. Kilgore, the head of the Coal and Energy Commission, flew over Coles Hill and stated that it was way out of the way of anything.
He doesn't think that we, the people of this county, are anything.
So let's show him that we are something by letting your supervisors know that you want to ban mining and milling of uranium.
The supervisors can do this if the regulations are stronger than the state.
A ban is stronger than a moratorium.
Allen Gross
Sheva, VA
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 9:33 AM EDT
I have been doing research on uranium mining and milling.
This is what I found: Marline stated that residents within a two-mile radius would have to relocate. Streams and wells would be lost for drinking purposes.
There was a study done in Michigan on the environmental impact on mining and milling of uranium.
Their findings for an open-pit uranium mine and mill was that there would have to be a buffer zone of 1,300 to 3,300 acres or two to five square miles.
Think a little bit. How many homes are in a square mile? How many acres of farm land will be useless? How many tax dollars the county will lose?
A couple of months ago, the county supervisors recognized the dairy farmers in the county.
The farmers stated in the last couple of years they hired 60 extra people.
The county will lose more tax revenue than it will gain if this mine and mill gets the ok.
The VanDerHyde's dairy is trying to get the ok and funding for an anaerobic digester to change cattle waste into electricity.
I think this is a good idea, and good for the environment.
None of this will happen when the air and water becomes contaminated.
People will not buy contaminated milk, hay, beef, or anything else raised or grown in the area surrounding a mine.
The mega park that the county supervisors have spent our tax money on will not happen. No company will come to this area if there are health risks.
Last November my wife and I, plus four others, went to West Virginia to see a mountain-top removal coal mine.
There was a town a few miles from the mine site. Everything was boarded up: schools, churches, gas stations, and stores.
It was a ghost town.
The mining company was following rules and regulations. Is this what we want for this county?
Don't wait for the study.
Mr. Kilgore, the head of the Coal and Energy Commission, flew over Coles Hill and stated that it was way out of the way of anything.
He doesn't think that we, the people of this county, are anything.
So let's show him that we are something by letting your supervisors know that you want to ban mining and milling of uranium.
The supervisors can do this if the regulations are stronger than the state.
A ban is stronger than a moratorium.
Allen Gross
Sheva, VA
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Attorney general opinion casts doubt on local uranium ban
Comment: People of Virginia, demand your local leaders to ban uranium mining and milling in Virginia!! Remember, It's "We the People, Not We the Corporations!!!" By TIM DAVIS/Star-Tribune Editor
Wednesday, June 10, 2009 10:36 AM EDT
Pittsylvania County does not have the authority to ban uranium mining, according to a recent opinion by the Virginia attorney general's office.
Late last month, County Administrator Dan Sleeper, acting on behalf of the Board of Supervisors, asked Sen. Robert Hurt to request an attorney general's opinion on whether the county could pass an ordinance banning uranium mining.
Hurt contacted the attorney general's office, which referred to a formal opinion issued on Nov. 14, 2008, that says localities cannot enact any law that "nullifies or pre-empts state or federal law."
To do so without express permission from the General Assembly would be unconstitutional, the opinion states.
The same opinion cast a shadow over so-called "chemical trespass" ordinances, which some localities, including Chatham, were considering for protection against uranium mining.
The idea for a ban on uranium mining was suggested by Karen Maute of Danville, a well-known zoning and environmental advocate.
Other residents opposed to uranium mining also have called for an outright ban.
Supervisors' Legislative Committee met in March to explore tightening the county's zoning ordinance, but tabled a possible ban.
"I think we need to address the issue and look at it closely and not make any hasty decisions one way or the other," said the committee's chairman, Staunton River District Supervisor Marshall Ecker.
The committee also includes Banister District Supervisor William Pritchett and Chatham-Blairs District Supervisor Henry "Hank" Davis Jr.
Davis recently pushed for a stronger resolution from supervisors on uranium mining.
The resolution, adopted unanimously in February, recommends that a state study determine uranium mining will cause "no damage or harm" to the county.
It was sent to the Virginia Coal and Energy Commission's Uranium Mining Subcommittee, which is conducting a comprehensive study on the dangers and benefits of uranium mining.
The Coles Hill uranium deposit about six miles northeast of Chatham is one of the largest deposits in the United States.
Even if the Coal and Energy Commission determines uranium mining can be done safely, the General Assembly would have to lift the state's moratorium, which has been in place since 1982.
The board's chairman, Westover District Supervisor Coy Harville, said it's a state issue.
"Right now all we can do is listen," he said. "The state has a moratorium and I respect that. They have more authority than we do."
According to the attorney general's opinion, "a Virginia locality may not enact an ordinance that diminishes, alters, or eliminates legal rights, particularly where the state or federal government may be said to 'occupy the field," unless given specific authority to do so by the General Assembly or the Congress of the United States."
The four-page opinion was issued at the request of Del. Riley E. Ingram of Hopewell.
The attorney general said county and municipal ordinances must be consistent with the laws of the commonwealth.
"Thus, if an entity operates in compliance with state law, a Virginia locality cannot impose a criminal liability on that entity," said the attorney general.
"Likewise, a locality may not prohibit or limit the authority of state or federal agencies to carry out their duties as prescribed by law."
Supervisors could still ban uranium mining, but a ban would likely be overturned in court.
Even if the General Assembly eventually lifts Virginia's moratorium, state and federal laws would govern uranium mining and processing.
Supervisors also would have to rezone the Coles Hill property and Virginia Uranium Inc., which is hoping to mine the deposit, would have to obtain a special-use permit from the Board of Zoning Appeals.
Hurt said it appears the attorney general's opinion addresses the county's question on a possible ban on uranium mining.
However, in a June 3 letter to Sleeper, the senator said, "In the event that you do not believe this opinion fully answers your request , I will be happy to follow up with the attorney general's office."
tim.davis@chathamstartribune.com
(434) 432-2791
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2009/06/10/chatham/news/news51.txt
Wednesday, June 10, 2009 10:36 AM EDT
Pittsylvania County does not have the authority to ban uranium mining, according to a recent opinion by the Virginia attorney general's office.
Late last month, County Administrator Dan Sleeper, acting on behalf of the Board of Supervisors, asked Sen. Robert Hurt to request an attorney general's opinion on whether the county could pass an ordinance banning uranium mining.
Hurt contacted the attorney general's office, which referred to a formal opinion issued on Nov. 14, 2008, that says localities cannot enact any law that "nullifies or pre-empts state or federal law."
To do so without express permission from the General Assembly would be unconstitutional, the opinion states.
The same opinion cast a shadow over so-called "chemical trespass" ordinances, which some localities, including Chatham, were considering for protection against uranium mining.
The idea for a ban on uranium mining was suggested by Karen Maute of Danville, a well-known zoning and environmental advocate.
Other residents opposed to uranium mining also have called for an outright ban.
Supervisors' Legislative Committee met in March to explore tightening the county's zoning ordinance, but tabled a possible ban.
"I think we need to address the issue and look at it closely and not make any hasty decisions one way or the other," said the committee's chairman, Staunton River District Supervisor Marshall Ecker.
The committee also includes Banister District Supervisor William Pritchett and Chatham-Blairs District Supervisor Henry "Hank" Davis Jr.
Davis recently pushed for a stronger resolution from supervisors on uranium mining.
The resolution, adopted unanimously in February, recommends that a state study determine uranium mining will cause "no damage or harm" to the county.
It was sent to the Virginia Coal and Energy Commission's Uranium Mining Subcommittee, which is conducting a comprehensive study on the dangers and benefits of uranium mining.
The Coles Hill uranium deposit about six miles northeast of Chatham is one of the largest deposits in the United States.
Even if the Coal and Energy Commission determines uranium mining can be done safely, the General Assembly would have to lift the state's moratorium, which has been in place since 1982.
The board's chairman, Westover District Supervisor Coy Harville, said it's a state issue.
"Right now all we can do is listen," he said. "The state has a moratorium and I respect that. They have more authority than we do."
According to the attorney general's opinion, "a Virginia locality may not enact an ordinance that diminishes, alters, or eliminates legal rights, particularly where the state or federal government may be said to 'occupy the field," unless given specific authority to do so by the General Assembly or the Congress of the United States."
The four-page opinion was issued at the request of Del. Riley E. Ingram of Hopewell.
The attorney general said county and municipal ordinances must be consistent with the laws of the commonwealth.
"Thus, if an entity operates in compliance with state law, a Virginia locality cannot impose a criminal liability on that entity," said the attorney general.
"Likewise, a locality may not prohibit or limit the authority of state or federal agencies to carry out their duties as prescribed by law."
Supervisors could still ban uranium mining, but a ban would likely be overturned in court.
Even if the General Assembly eventually lifts Virginia's moratorium, state and federal laws would govern uranium mining and processing.
Supervisors also would have to rezone the Coles Hill property and Virginia Uranium Inc., which is hoping to mine the deposit, would have to obtain a special-use permit from the Board of Zoning Appeals.
Hurt said it appears the attorney general's opinion addresses the county's question on a possible ban on uranium mining.
However, in a June 3 letter to Sleeper, the senator said, "In the event that you do not believe this opinion fully answers your request , I will be happy to follow up with the attorney general's office."
tim.davis@chathamstartribune.com
(434) 432-2791
http://www.wpcva.com/articles/2009/06/10/chatham/news/news51.txt
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


