Monday, March 4, 2013

Canadian Lakes and Streams at Risk




 by MiningWatch Canada

These natural lakes and streams have been or are at risk of being "re-classified" as waste dumps for the mining industry.

This is possible to thanks to Schedule 2 of the Metal Mining Effluent Regulations which was added in 2002.

The first listings were used to grandfather ongoing operations but since 2006 it has been used to condemn pristine lakes and streams.

Colour code for markers: yellow are original listings from 2002, purple are lakes that have been listed since 2002, red are in the process of being listed and blue were at risk but have been saved by citizen action and environmental reviews.

Click here to see the map:

https://maps.google.ca/maps/ms?msid=211927718733683723427.000489403d13e90d0a3d8&msa=0
www.miningwatch.ca

 
Done
Canadian Lakes and Streams at Risk by MiningWatch Canada
These natural lakes and streams have been or are at risk of being "re-classified" as waste dumps for the mining industry. This is possible to thanks to Schedule 2 of the Metal Mining Effluent Regulations which was added in 2002. The first listings were used to grandfather ongoing operations but since 2006 it has been used to condemn pristine lakes and streams.

Colour code for markers: yellow are original listings from 2002, purple are lakes that have been listed since 2002, red are in the process of being listed and blue were at risk but have been saved by citizen action and environmental reviews.

www.miningwatch.ca
Amazay (Duncan Lake)
Northgate Minerals proposed to construct a large open pit mine and dump tailings into Amazay against the objection of First Nations in the area. The project was not approved following joint provi...

Northgate Minerals proposed to construct a large open pit mine and dump tailings into Amazay against the objection of First Nations in the area.
The project was not approved following joint provincial-federal environmental assessment that found the project was not in the public interest.

 
Bamoos Lake
Bamoos Lake is a natural Lake Trout Lake and was proposed as one of two options for mine waste disposal by Marathon PGM.The company has since committed to using an alternative site for the tailings b...
Bamoos Lake is a natural Lake Trout Lake and was proposed as one of two options for mine waste disposal by Marathon PGM.The company has since committed to using an alternative site for the tailings but the other option would still involve the destruction of fish-bearing water bodies.
Teztan Biny (Fish Lake)
Taseko Mines Ltd. proposed to drain Fish lake and fill in the Little Fish Lake and Fish Creek watershed with tailings. The proposal was opposed by the Tsilhqot'in and Secwepemc Nations, MiningWatch Ca...

Taseko Mines Ltd. proposed to drain Fish lake and fill in the Little Fish Lake and Fish Creek watershed with tailings. The proposal was opposed by the Tsilhqot'in and Secwepemc Nations, MiningWatch Canada and many other organizations. The BC government approved the project despite finding it would have significant negative environmental effects and acknowledging that concerns regarding groundwater contamination remained unanswered. The federal government required a much more rigorous assessment by a review panel that found the project would have a number of significant negative effects. Based on the federal panel report the federal Cabinet rejected the project.

Black Lake, Quarry and Trail Crk
Imperial Metal's Red Chris project underwent a provincial environmental assessment but the federal government only conducted a screening, contrary to what the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act req...
Imperial Metal's Red Chris project underwent a provincial environmental assessment but the federal government only conducted a screening, contrary to what the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act requires. MiningWatch and Ecojustice took the federal government all the way to the Supreme Court to ensure full assessments including public participation are conducted by the federal government. This large open pit mine is of concern to the Tahltan Nation and remains a concern to MiningWatch.
Bucko Lake
Bucko Lake is proposed to be the tailings dump for Crowflight Minerals' Bucko Lake Mine. The mine is currently operating with a temporary tailings impoundment pending approval from the federal governm...
Bucko Lake is proposed to be the tailings dump for Crowflight Minerals' Bucko Lake Mine. The mine is currently operating with a temporary tailings impoundment pending approval from the federal government.

Ruby Creek
A molybdenum mine proposed by Adanac Minerals received federal and provincial approvals. The potentially affected stream was not listed on Schedule 2 because the company ran into financial problems ...
A molybdenum mine proposed by Adanac Minerals received federal and provincial approvals. The potentially affected stream was not listed on Schedule 2 because the company ran into financial problems and the project is not proceeding at this time.
Various ponds and streams - Bending Lake Area
Though avoiding the larger lakes near by, the Josephine Cone mine's tailings area will still impact a number of fish-bearing streams and ponds. The project is going through a federal environmental ass...
Though avoiding the larger lakes near by, the Josephine Cone mine's tailings area will still impact a number of fish-bearing streams and ponds. The project is going through a federal environmental assessment in 2013.
Clet Creek
The Clet Creek watershed is the proposed location for the tailings area of the Arnaud Apatite project just outside Sept-Iles, Quebec. Local residents have a number of concerns about the project's impa...
The Clet Creek watershed is the proposed location for the tailings area of the Arnaud Apatite project just outside Sept-Iles, Quebec. Local residents have a number of concerns about the project's impacts given its proximity to the town and rural residences. In addition to impacts on waterways and groundwater, noise, dust and traffic may all impact the environment and quality of life in the community.
Winter Lake
Yellowknife Gold's Tyhee gold mine is currently in advanced exploration phase. Once in production it proposes to use Winter Lake for tailings disposal. The project was being reviewed by the McKenzie V...


Yellowknife Gold's Tyhee gold mine is currently in advanced exploration phase. Once in production it proposes to use Winter Lake for tailings disposal. The project was being reviewed by the McKenzie Valley Review Board but Yellowknife Gold requested the project be withdrawn and intends to resubmit the application.
Bird Brook
Provincial and federal EA's are underway for the Sisson Brook Project that has proposed a tailings impoundment in the Bird Brook watershed. This project is in the upper watershed of the largest viable...
Provincial and federal EA's are underway for the Sisson Brook Project that has proposed a tailings impoundment in the Bird Brook watershed. This project is in the upper watershed of the largest viable Atlantic salmon river in the Saint John River watershed.
Y'anah Biny
The destruction of Y'anah Biny (Little Fish Lake) and Teztan Biny (Fish Lake) were prevented when in 2011 the federal government rejected Taseko Mine Ltd.'s proposed Prosperity Gold-Copper Project. In...
The destruction of Y'anah Biny (Little Fish Lake) and Teztan Biny (Fish Lake) were prevented when in 2011 the federal government rejected Taseko Mine Ltd.'s proposed Prosperity Gold-Copper Project. In In August 2011 Taseko resubmitted a revised mine plan that would not drain Teztan Biny but would still fill in Y'anah Biny and the upper Fish Creek watershed with tailings. Based on the findings of the Review Panel the revised mine plan would do little to protect the ecological and cultural values of Teztan Biny.
Lac Hessé
This is one of several lakes that have been sacrificed by the iron ore mining sector along the Quebec-Labrador border. It's not clear how this lake has continued to be used as a tailings dump without ...
This is one of several lakes that have been sacrificed by the iron ore mining sector along the Quebec-Labrador border. It's not clear how this lake has continued to be used as a tailings dump without proper authorizations.

Environment Canada announced plans to add it to Schedule 2 early in 2013.
Various ponds and streams near Marathon
Though Bamoos Lake is no longer being proposed as the tailings area for the Marathon Project, several smaller lakes and streams may be inundated by the proposed tailings area in the new mine plan.
Though Bamoos Lake is no longer being proposed as the tailings area for the Marathon Project, several smaller lakes and streams may be inundated by the proposed tailings area in the new mine plan.
King Richard Creek
Terrane Metals' Mt. Milligan mining operation will dump tailings waste into the King Richard Creek Valley. The project has been opposed by the Nak'azdli First Nation which has traditional family terri...
Terrane Metals' Mt. Milligan mining operation will dump tailings waste into the King Richard Creek Valley. The project has been opposed by the Nak'azdli First Nation which has traditional family territories at the mine site. The McLeod Lake Band, which includes the area in their land claim with BC have supported the project.

MiningWatch's review of the Fish Habitat Compensation plan raised concerns about the long-term viability and likely success of achieving the "Not Net Loss" objective.

 
Trout Pond
Trout Pond is now receiving tailings from Teck's Duck Pond copper mine near Bucchans NL. In 2006 it was the first pristine lake to be re-classified under Schedule 2. LINKS MiningWatch Teck
Trout Pond is now receiving tailings from Teck's Duck Pond copper mine near Bucchans NL. In 2006 it was the first pristine lake to be re-classified under Schedule 2.
Flora Lake
Added to Schedule 2 in 2009, Flora Lake had been receiving iron ore mine waste for many years before listing.

Added to Schedule 2 in 2009, Flora Lake had been receiving iron ore mine waste for many years before listing.
Sandy Pond
Brazilian mining company Vale is constructing a hydromet nickel refining plant in Long Harbour NL. The company has received federal and provincial approvals to dump the waste from the facility into ...


Brazilian mining company Vale is constructing a hydromet nickel refining plant in Long Harbour NL. The company has received federal and provincial approvals to dump the waste from the facility into Sandy Pond. This required a further amendment to the MMER and Schedule 2 (2009) that permits listed water bodies to receive not only mine tailings but also hydromet processing wastes.

The pond (a decent sized lake) is home to trophy brook trout as well as land-locked American eel and rainbow smelt.

In an effort to save Sandy Pond, the Sandy Pond Alliance has launched a legal challenge questioning the legality of Schedule 2 given the purpose and intent of the Fisheries Act.
Second Portage Lake (NW Arm)
Second Portage Lake is now the tailings impoundment for the Meadowbank Gold Mine operated by Agnico Eagle. The mine began pouring gold in 2010. Links for more information Nunavut Impact Review Boa...

Second Portage Lake is now the tailings impoundment for the Meadowbank Gold Mine operated by Agnico Eagle. The mine began pouring gold in 2010.
Mallard Lake
A lake which has already been used for waste disposal and is contaminated with heavy metals continues to contaminate downstream lakes and streams. Canadian Environmental Assessment
A lake which has already been used for waste disposal and is contaminated with heavy metals continues to contaminate downstream lakes and streams.

Canadian Environmental Assessment
Tail Lake
Newmont's Doris North project was approved in 2008 and once in production will use Tail Lake for tailings disposal. Links for more information Nunavut Impact Review Board

Newmont's Doris North project was approved in 2008 and once in production will use Tail Lake for tailings disposal.

Links for more information
Nunavut Impact Review Board
Wabush Lake
Wabush Lake was added to Schedule 2 in 2009. The lake had been receiving iron ore mine waste for many years before. geoscienceworld wikipedia
Wabush Lake was added to Schedule 2 in 2009. The lake had been receiving iron ore mine waste for many years before.


geoscienceworld
wikipedia
Teigen Creek/Treaty Creek
The KSM is currently undergoing comprehensive federal and a provincial environmental assessment. Current information suggests that Teigan Creek and Treaty Creek may have fish, but no details have been...


The KSM is currently undergoing comprehensive federal and a provincial environmental assessment. Current information suggests that Teigan Creek and Treaty Creek may have fish, but no details have been provided.
Un-named pond and creek (Detour Gold)
This small muskeg pond and creek are the location of a new tailings impoundment for the Detour Lake Mine, a large open-pit gold mine being constructed at the site of a former, much smaller open pit. T...
This small muskeg pond and creek are the location of a new tailings impoundment for the Detour Lake Mine, a large open-pit gold mine being constructed at the site of a former, much smaller open pit. The pond and creek had a low diversity of fish present and the project was approved with the support of First Nations in the area.
Albino Lake
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment. Canada Gazette
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.


Canada Gazette
Anderson Lake
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.

Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.

Garrow Lake
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.

Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.
South Kemess Creek
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment. CEAA
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.



CEAA
Tom McKay Lake
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment. govbc
Listed in 2002 as part of original Schedule 2 amendment.



govbc
Clary Creek